To Milk or Not to Milk? How to Pick a Coffee Blend That Actually Works for You

When it comes to coffee, there are a few questions that quietly shape every cup: milk, or no milk? Foam or no foam? Soy or almond? 

Whether you're pouring a silky flat white or sipping something straight-up, the kind of coffee you start with makes all the difference. At Black Market Coffee, we’ve roasted a trio of blends to meet you where you're at, whether you're just getting started, refining your brew game, or like your coffee bold enough to stand up on its own (or with a splash of milk, of course).

Here’s how to find the right match for your mug:

Oh! Blend – For the ‘Just Getting into Coffee’ Crowd

If you’re newer to the coffee scene, or just want something easy-drinking and mellow, Oh! Blend is your new bestie. It’s organic, roasted light-medium, and has a soft, honeycomb and caramel vibe that makes it super approachable.

Tastes like: honeycomb, caramel, chocolate
Best with: milk or black – it’s friendly either way
Why you’ll love it: It’s mellow without being boring. Great for that first morning cup that doesn’t hit too hard.

Liberty – The All-Rounder You Can Rely On

If you’ve been drinking coffee for a while and want something balanced and smooth, Liberty Blend is your go-to. It hits that sweet spot that’s just rich enough to feel indulgent, but clean and smooth enough to enjoy however you like.

Tastes like: cocoa, caramel, a touch of fruit
Best with: black or milk – it holds its own both ways
Why you’ll love it: It’s got enough character to keep things interesting, but still plays nicely with milk. Your everyday blend.

Rhythm – For the Bold Drinkers

Let’s say you love a strong, classic coffee with plenty of punch. Rhythm Blend is for you, my friend. Inspired by the kind of deep, rich espresso you’d find in an old-school Italian café, Rhythm is low acid and high in flavour.

Tastes like: dark chocolate, rich nut, bold
Best with: milk – not recommended black
Why you’ll love it: It cuts through milk like a champ. Big, bold in flavour, without the bitterness.

How Do You Like Your Espresso?

There’s no wrong way to drink coffee, but the right blend makes a huge difference. Start light with Oh!, settle into something smooth with Liberty, or go big with Rhythm. Wherever you’re at in your coffee journey, we’ve roasted something you can enjoy.